TL;DR
Get baking supplies delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
The Kitchn’s Ali Domrongchai taste-tested several UNREAL candies with six family members and reported that every taster chose Peanut Butter Drops as their top pick. The review is an informal tasting, not a controlled comparison; it also lists six other candies, with the Peanut Butter Drops offered at the lowest listed price per package.
The Kitchn’s Ali Domrongchai reports that Peanut Butter Drops were the top choice for all seven people in an informal tasting of UNREAL candies, including the writer and six family members. The result points readers to a clear favorite in the brand’s assortment, while the tasting does not establish a broader consumer preference or a formal product ranking.
Domrongchai said she gathered several of UNREAL’s milk- and dark-chocolate candies for a head-to-head tasting with her family. She wrote that the group found all the candies enjoyable, so the article presents them from “good to great” rather than treating the lower-ranked options as poor products. The seven-person group was small and personally selected, making the findings a set of tasting impressions rather than a representative survey.
Peanut Butter Drops took the top spot. Unlike chocolate-coated peanut butter candies, Domrongchai described these as creamy peanut butter surrounded by a candy shell. She said the flavor was lightly sweetened and the shell’s crunch was a draw for tasters. The source lists a price of $23.07 for three 4-ounce bags through UNREAL; prices may change, and the article says its prices were accurate when published.
The rest of the list includes Dark Chocolate Caramel Peanut Nougat Bars, Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups, Dark Chocolate Peanut Gems, Dark Chocolate Coconut Bars, Milk Chocolate Gems and Dark Chocolate Almond Butter Cups. The caramel-and-peanut bars ranked just below the winner, with testers praising their balance of sweetness and dark chocolate. The article lists two-bag prices of $29.43 for most of the other products, with the peanut gems listed at $29.42.
A Practical Guide to UNREAL’s Range
The tasting offers shoppers a side-by-side account of how several UNREAL candies compare in flavor and texture, rather than relying on product descriptions alone. For readers deciding what to try, the unanimous preference for Peanut Butter Drops is a useful recommendation from this particular group, and the listed package price gives a point of reference.
That recommendation has limits. The sample consisted of one editor and six family members, and the source does not describe a blind test, standardized scoring or a comparison with competing brands. Taste is personal, and the result should be read as a product review, not proof that the drops are the most popular choice among UNREAL customers.
Products Worth Considering
KitchenAid Artisan 5-Quart Tilt-Head Stand Mixer, Almond Cream
Ninja Artisan Outdoor Pizza Oven, 5-in-1, 700°F, Gray (MO201)
Instant Pot InstantChill Ice Cream Maker with Rolled Ice Cream Plate, No Pre-Freezing, 2-Pint
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
How the Family Taste Test Worked
Domrongchai writes about groceries for The Kitchn and said she was already a fan of UNREAL’s Dark Chocolate Coconut Bars before organizing the tasting. She gathered the brand’s available milk- and dark-chocolate candies for the family comparison. The earlier positive experience gives useful context, but it also means the reviewer was not approaching the brand as an unfamiliar product category.
In the article, the products are described through their ingredients and eating qualities. The coconut bars, for example, are said to contain three ingredients: organic coconut, organic cassava syrup and dark chocolate. The source also says UNREAL’s ingredients are fair-trade, certified non-GMO and gluten-free, and that the candies use natural colorants and contain no additives or artificial sugars. Those are statements made in the review; the article does not provide independent verification or product-by-product certification details.
““Every single one of my family members put these Peanut Butter Drops as their number-one pick.””
— Ali Domrongchai, The Kitchn
Limits of the Seven-Person Sample
The article does not say whether the candies were tasted blind, how the products were scored, or whether every available UNREAL flavor was included. It also gives no information about participants’ allergies, dietary preferences or prior familiarity with the candies. The claim that Peanut Butter Drops were the group’s unanimous favorite applies only to the seven tasters in this review; no company sales data or wider consumer polling is provided.
The listed prices are a snapshot from the time the article was published, not a guarantee of current cost or availability. The source also does not provide full nutrition panels or detailed evidence for its broader ingredient and certification statements.
Check Current Prices Before Ordering
Readers interested in the winner can check UNREAL’s current product listing for Peanut Butter Drops, since the review’s price may no longer apply. The Kitchn article invites readers to share their favorite UNREAL candy, but it does not announce another tasting or any company product change. For now, the reported next step is a shopper’s choice: try the featured drops or select another candy from the tasting based on its flavor and texture.
Key Questions
Which UNREAL candy won the taste test?
Peanut Butter Drops were the top choice for the writer and all six family members who took part.
What are UNREAL Peanut Butter Drops made like?
Domrongchai describes them as creamy peanut butter in a candy shell, rather than peanut butter coated in chocolate. The review says they are lightly sweetened.
How much did the Peanut Butter Drops cost in the article?
The source listed $23.07 for three 4-ounce bags at UNREAL when the article was published. That price may have changed.
Was this a formal or blind taste test?
The report describes a tasting with the writer and six family members, but does not say it was blind or use a formal scoring method. Its result reflects that small group’s preferences.
Were the other candies disliked?
No. Domrongchai said the tasters found the candies enjoyable and organized the list from “good to great”, rather than ranking them as bad-to-good.
Source: thekitchn.com
![Eating Out [Grickle]](https://patiopie.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/eating-out-grickle-featured-560x300.jpg)
